Painted Pony Restaurant - Bethlehem, Connecticut

Okay, here’s a detailed overview of the Painted Pony Restaurant, designed to be a helpful and informative resource for potential patrons:

Painted Pony Restaurant: A Detailed Recommendation

For those seeking a pleasant and versatile dining experience in Bethlehem, Connecticut, the Painted Pony Restaurant presents a compelling option. Located at 74 Main St S, Bethlehem, CT 06751, United States, this establishment offers a welcoming atmosphere and a broad range of culinary and service features. The restaurant’s telephone number is 2032665771, and you can find more detailed information, including their menu and events, on their website: paintedponyrestaurant.net.

Restaurant Characteristics & Specialties

The Painted Pony is primarily an American restaurant, providing a classic selection of dishes designed to satisfy a variety of tastes. They’ve cultivated a reputation for offering comfort food – hearty, satisfying meals that are perfect for a casual visit. Beyond the standard fare, they cater to a broader audience with vegetarian options and a focus on providing a well-rounded menu, including small plates and a selection of desserts.

Points of Interest & Amenities

The restaurant’s appeal extends beyond its food. It boasts several desirable features, including outdoor seating, allowing guests to enjoy their meal in a pleasant setting. They also offer convenient services such as takeaway, dine-in, and delivery. The staff is known for their fast service, and the ambiance is enhanced by a charming fireplace. For those who appreciate a good beverage, the Painted Pony is recognized for its great beer selection, great cocktails, and a great wine list. Adding to the entertainment, they regularly feature live music, and cater to sports enthusiasts.

Accessibility is a priority; the restaurant is wheelchair-accessible, with a wheelchair-accessible car park and wheelchair-accessible entrance, along with designated wheelchair-accessible seating and a wheelchair-accessible toilet. They accept a variety of payment methods, including credit cards and debit cards, and also welcome reservations. The restaurant is family-friendly, offering high chairs and a kids' menu.

Customer Feedback & Ratings

The Painted Pony has garnered significant attention from its patrons, with a substantial 341 reviews on Google My Business. The average opinion is 4.3/5, indicating a generally positive experience. Based on these reviews, the restaurant is frequently praised for its cleanliness, friendly service, and the quality of its food – particularly the well-presented and flavorful dishes. The atmosphere is often described as cozy and casual and is well suited for groups, tourists, and those seeking a solo dining experience.

Recommended Services & Facilities

• Wi-Fi Access
• Bar on Site
• Restroom
• Free Parking Lot & Street Parking

To ensure you have the most up-to-date information on their menu, hours, events, and to make a reservation, we strongly recommend visiting their website: paintedponyrestaurant.net.

Overall, the Painted Pony Restaurant presents a delightful and well-equipped dining destination. We encourage you to explore their website and plan your visit

👍 Reviews of Painted Pony Restaurant

Steve A.

4/5

We stopped here after our visit to March farm in Bethlehem where we picked up pumpkins and the best apple cider doughnuts. We stopped in at the Painted Pony around 3 in the afternoon . The place was empty which is a shame since it’s a good place . Everything was spotless and the service was good . My wife had the chicken avocado sandwich and a side salad , I had the flatbread topped with Asiago cheese, short rib and tomatoes. Both were presented well and tasty, nothing mind blowing but worth the money , if your in the area give it a try .

Valon S.

5/5

Amazing service is an understatement. The new painted pony restaurant is an amazing place for people of all Ages with events all through the week such as trivia on Tuesdays and bands every Saturday this place has it all. The amazing menu is only beat by the amazing food options. The fries are amazing and while there are many pasta dishes the chicken parm in particular is amazing don’t listen to what the haters say the painted pony is an amazing place for you and the whole family. I will be coming back.

Michael G. G.

2/5

appetizers were great but what I order steak tips I don't expect a steak cut into pieces those were not sirloin tips I asked for medium rare I got well my friend ordered a New York strip it was so fatty she complained was nice about it chef looks it up online to see how much fat should be on it so that tells me they are not a chef and did not honor giving another one and taken back the fat one so it cost me over $30 for the steak tips that were not sirloin steak tips overcooked and they were too cheap to honor the New York strip which she did not ask for her money back she just wanted another one your restaurant has went downhill again I have never heard of a so-called Chef to look up what a New York strip should be like let's call the sky a kitchen worker that has no concept of temping steak because you definitely screwed up my fake steak tips

Erich W.

5/5

A really great place oozing atmosphere.
Great food residency priced, with many drink options.
The specialty drinks were not priced and cost more then we'd expected at $12, but we're very well made.
Get the wings and the jalapeno dip (request extra jalapeno).
I'm told the calamari is very good as well.
Great attentive service, with smiles all around

Thomas H. I.

5/5

Awesome place for food, drinks, and music! The owner Missy is super friendly and extremely accommodating. The chef always has specials and are a great change from typical menu items at most places. The daily menu is diverse and everything I've had to date has been great. We love this place!

JENNEKEN R.

3/5

Service was great the food was ok. My baked fish was tuff and had no flavor and my broccoli was obviously frozen and water logged. Chicken parmesan was obviously premade, the tomatoe sauce was also not fresh or homemade. The place had a musty smell. The dining room looked refurbished. Good bread. Great service average food.

tarlea L.

3/5

Service was good .. food mediocre.. but what upset me the most was there was flies and one landed on my food.. won’t be back..

Brian L.

4/5

Food was very good, although it took too long to get it..
Entertainment was very good, overall we had a nice time.