Lake Martin Pizza Co. - Dadeville, Alabama

Dave S.

We ordered from lake Martin pizza in Dadeville twice over the course of a few months and both times were the same…bad. Service is abysmal and taste is blah. If they tell you 25-30 minutes expect to wait 45-60 as I did today. Last time I ordered and paid for a full (12) order of garlic knots, but they gave me 6. I told them and they didn’t care. Today the order took two minutes short of forever (they said 30 minutes) and they didn’t seem to care. There were lots of people waiting. The 4-5 high school kids working were overwhelmed to say the least. Once I finally got our order the crust was hard with no flavor and overall the pizza just didn’t taste good. Pretty much same as before but we wanted to give them another shot at it. It was the same and In fact, the garlic knots tasted better than the pizza. The only way this place can still be in business is because there aren’t many other options. And the price isn’t cheap, so I would probably eat elsewhere or do takeout from any other place around there before getting burned a third time.

C. B.

Best pizza this side of Blue Creek. We get take out from here at least a couple of times per month. I remember what life was like before Lake Martin Pizza existed... I hope we never have to go back to those dark days.

Shelby A.

Although the atmosphere of the restaurant was great, the pizza itself was maybe a 2.5...super dry (not enough marinara) and although it was dark on the bottom, the crust hadn't been fully cooked through.

We would have purchased dessert if they had it available, but after having the pizza, I'm glad we didn't.

We added the Parm you see here, but got a build your own with sausage, bacon, and green peppers. It's clear they don't homemaker their sausage (it's the freezer stuff) and we were really unsatisfied.

L. J. S.

We have been coming to Lake Martin Pizza for years. Something is definitely off since being under new ownership. Customer service used to be great but is awful now. Unfortunately it's the only show in town.

Joni A.

Went here based on a local recommendation! Glad we went! The outside patio looks amazing, a little too chilly for us so we dined inside! The staff was super friendly! We ordered a Hawaiian and a cheese w pepperoni and banana peppers! It was delicious, the sauce was great the pizza was cooked to perfection! The table behind us had ordered the dill pickle pizza and when I say the locals are friendly I mean it! They overheard us talking about the sill pickle pizza and offered us a piece to try! OMG if you go to LMP you must get the dill pickle pizza! It’s the perfect amount of garlic and pickles enough to make your tastebuds go pickle crazy! We were so hungry we forgot to snap photos of the pizza itself but it’s definitely a must try if you are near by!

Marie N.

We are in town for the weekend to look at maybe moving here. Our realtor said to go to Lake Martin Pizza because it’s the best so of course we went there! We called our pizza in to go and was told 45 minutes. We were done with our run around and went there in 30 minutes…walked in the door and was greeted by a young man and woman telling us oh that order won’t be done until we finish this …which was rolling up pizza dough for later use….nobody else was at the restaurant and they stood there talking and laughing while making the cut dough perfect for later knowing you have a paying take out customer waiting…..we even got pushed 10 minutes back and then on top there was not cheese covering the whole margarita pizza….which is pretty much cheese and tomatoes…great dough…..great pizza of you just add the cheese but maybe install a sense of paying customer vs how many premade pizza dough do we need for tonight…

April D.

Normally I love the pizza at Lake Martin Pizza, but I received a burnt pizza on a Saturday night(3/26/22). I didn’t notice it until I returned home about 15 miles away. I stopped by the next Saturday and showed pictures to one of the guys working there and was told that’s how the pizzas look. I really hate he low rated Lake Martin pizza by saying that. Before that day, I had never received pizza with the entire crust like a burnt cracker and the cheese and meat were tough. Make sure you look at your pizza before leaving. I know I will. Just assumed the employees were trustworthy.

Sam G. J.

The pizza is amazing! I was on my way back to Atlanta and had to stop. They had a live band who came while we were eating outside. The have a bar with TVs outside as well. We had a veggie pizza, chicken pizza and garlic knots. Everything was great.