Bodega Bay Oyster Company - Petaluma, California

Jordana M.

Was so excited to try this place after reading the reviews and hearing great things. However, it was not a good experience. The service was lackluster and it seemed like no one cared if you were interested in the oysters or not and seemed like they were all annoyed to be working there.
My family of 6 were celebrating a birthday, we came in ordered one wine flight, two assorted oyster flights and one of the baked assorted. The order was delivered and just set on the table with no care or explanation on what wine/oysters were which. The Chardonnay tasted off, other two wines were good, figured out which ones were which on my own. The baked oysters were pretty decent in flavor but gave us stomachaches later on which was a little worrisome.
We waited and waited for the other two oyster trays since they never arrived and staff didn't seem to notice or care. Finally went back to the ladies at the register to ask and the rest of our order was completely forgotten. No apology really after those were delivered.
Your oysters are good your service just needs to match. We almost bought another round of fresh oysters but I chose not to due to the hospitality, so you lost out on some revenue there.
At this point I would not return or recommend Bodega Bay Oyster Co. based on the service received and warn and prepare others for what they may experience.

Alethea D.

I love this place so much. It’s worth my long drive for the lovely atmosphere, to die for oysters and welcoming staff. I have two hoodies from them and we go for special occasions.

Jennifer H.

This may very well be THE BEST BLT I have ever eaten! I got it to go and drove 10/15 minutes to my campsite and it was STILL good. Lots of bacon and bread so perfect. I didn't even want to share the crust with my spoiled Doberman. Everything was in the perfect amount. I am dreaming of my next excuse to stop by this place.

Shaun

Very friendly staff, nice outdoor seating, great food, decent selection on the menu. We were starting a "progressive lunch" of stopping here for oysters and then snag some chowdah over in Bodega Bay. Tried out the "Taster Plate" of grilled oysters which gives you three of the "Japanese BBQ Sauce" and three of the "Bacon Butter".

I went in thinking the bacon was going to dominate the oyster - it didn't at all. Perfect blend of fresh parsley, bacon butter, and caramelized onions. So good! Wish we ordered all six of those.

The Japanese BBQ Sauce was a salt bomb in your mouth —maybe less sauce, add a smidge of grated ginger and we are good. It read on the menu like it was going to be the winner between the two.

Absolutely will go back!

Jem L.

We came on the perfect day to try quite a few of their oyster varieties. The DIY price is great but if you prefer not to have your hand accidentally poked by the shucker, go with the half shelf option, your order will be served up very promptly and oh boy, aren't they the freshest that can be! It is like a piece of heaven in your mouth.

bartellj

So glad we stopped! This roadside oyster bar was just what we wanted. Much cheaper than Tomales Bay and the line was WAY SHORTER! We go a sample platter and everything was tasty. I really liked the grilled oysters! They also have a good wine selection. The atmosphere was great and easy to park

Stephanie

Short of the fact that the prices are off the hook the food was great. My 2 tacos was 15 dollars so, yeah. Service is perfect. The environment is very inviting. I would go back since it would be a rare occasion but not a regular type of location for food.

Steve H.

Great food! I had the clam chowder a blt and a draft beer. Even got some oysters to go. I have been here a couple times and it’s always good