Hornstra Dairy Farm - Whitman, Massachusetts

Konstantinos T.

We were in the area and had a craving for some Ice Cream Sundaes. They had a great variety of flavors. We ordered 2 Hot Fudge Sundaes 😋and a Hot Caramel Sundae 😋 they were so Delicious 😋. The Service was Excellent 👍.
Highly Recommend Hornstra Dairy Farm! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

William K.

First and foremost it’s not the employees fault that the place is just awful. Let’s start with white walls with no seeming seeing what it replaced had a whimsical inside and served high-quality ice cream. This place has a white pretentious and boring inside that suggested sterile and does not welcome people with really low quality ice cream. It may be fresh, but when you have to add simple syrup to a milkshake to make it taste like some thing there’s really something wrong with the ice cream. The pistachio ice cream doesn’t even taste like pistachio. It taste like milk with pistachios floating around the inside of it, compare that to the high-quality peaceful Meadows. That was there before hand. It’s a slap in the face at a price point that is laughably overpriced. You can get a higher quality ice cream Out of the freezer at your local grocery store.. Such a same 🙁

Zach S.

Hornstra Farm was very good. I gave 4 stars only because we were a little underwhelmed by the waffle cone quality and the variety of flavors. The ice cream is very good. Not the best in the area but very good and would return here again.

M's A.

I love having access to fresh, local milk. The ice cream is such a treat, and they have fun flavors that are different from the standard supermarket selection. Their pantry items are generally overpriced, but that's not what you go here for anyway.

Laura C.

I have been going to Peaceful Meadows since I was a kid and I was sad when I heard they were closing. I am so happy Hornstra Farms came along and we can still get yummy ice cream locally, and I heard they're bringing back the cows too! Now I buy farm fresh milk in glass bottles, local honey and other products in the store. They had egg nog for the holidays in lovely decorated bottles. I will be visiting often!

Amber N.

Love the milk, ice cream, all the essentials at the store besides the service. Our experience with the cashier has never been pleasant and never pays attention when we return bottles and have been over charged. Other than that experience we love the farm!

Nick C.

5-stars for keeping the Peaceful Meadows memories alive. New dairy store looks amazing. Excited to see what other improvements come. Haven’t had the ice cream, but they offer Coffee Oreo so they’re already ahead of the game.

My biggest issue is that they have understandably replaced all Peaceful Meadows dairy products with their own. I can only speak to the coffee milk, but it just can’t hold a candle to what Peaceful Meadows offered. If Peaceful’s coffee milk was 10/10, this new stuff is maybe a 3/10. It’s probably best for my health to stop drinking the stuff, so perhaps it’s a blessing in disguise.

RIP Peaceful Meadows coffee milk

Isabella T.

I left after they told me you're only allowed to have two toppings on a sundae, and that whipped cream and a cherry count as two. you can't even pay extra for more, you're just not allowed to have more than two! how is that even a sundae? with the prices you're charging, the sundae should actually BE a sundae!